It is accurate to state that ethical dilemmas in business
define us as being moral absolutists or moral situationalists.
always end up bringing out the best in us.
often force us to choose between equally unsatisfactory alternatives.
force us to make poor choices.
The correct answer and explanation is:
The correct answer is:
often force us to choose between equally unsatisfactory alternatives.
Explanation (300 words):
Ethical dilemmas in business frequently place individuals and organizations in situations where they must make challenging decisions involving conflicting values or principles. These dilemmas arise when multiple alternatives exist, but each choice carries significant ethical drawbacks or compromises. The distinctive feature of such dilemmas is precisely that they are not easily resolvable by straightforward reference to established ethical norms or rules.
Unlike moral absolutism, which dictates adherence to fixed ethical standards regardless of circumstance, ethical dilemmas reveal the complexity of real-life decision-making where rigid rules might not adequately apply. On the other hand, moral situationalists assert that ethical decisions depend heavily on the context and specific circumstances of each situation. While ethical dilemmas do test our ethical viewpoints, they do not necessarily categorize us neatly into absolutists or situationalists. Rather, they demonstrate how complicated ethical decisions can be in practical, real-world scenarios.
Moreover, ethical dilemmas do not always “bring out the best in us.” While sometimes they highlight integrity or moral courage, they can equally expose weaknesses, biases, and ethical inconsistencies. Individuals facing ethical dilemmas might experience distress, uncertainty, or even ethical failure.
The most accurate characterization is that ethical dilemmas often force us to choose between equally unsatisfactory alternatives. Each choice made under these circumstances can compromise some important ethical principle, potentially leading to regret or moral discomfort. Such dilemmas require careful reflection, balancing conflicting duties or values, and making decisions that inevitably involve some form of loss or dissatisfaction. Recognizing the inherent discomfort and complexity of ethical dilemmas prepares individuals and businesses to navigate these challenging choices thoughtfully, emphasizing the importance of ethical reasoning, reflection, and responsibility.