Answer the following questions. Section Break(Continuous) Section Break(Continuous) 1. How would the story be different if it were told from Jim’s perspective rather than Della’s? 2. Why might the author have chosen to tell the story from Della’s perspective? 3. Would you praise or blame Jim and Della’s selfless sacrifices? 4. Given the reaction of both Jim and Della concerning the entire situation, do you think that these gifts were appreciated? Why or why not? 5. How do you think you would react if you found yourself in a similar situation? 6. Often those who receive gifts are unaware of the sacrifice that the giver makes in order to give gifts. What can we learn from Jim and Della about receiving gifts and giving gifts?
The Correct Answer and Explanation is:
- If the story were told from Jim’s perspective rather than Della’s, the narrative would focus more on his emotions, thoughts, and motivations behind his sacrifice. Instead of experiencing Della’s anxiety and desperation firsthand, we would understand Jim’s perspective on their financial struggles, his attachment to his prized possession, and his reasoning for selling it. The shift in viewpoint might also emphasize different themes, such as his reflection on love, the significance of personal sacrifice, and his anticipation of Della’s reaction.
- The author likely chose to tell the story from Della’s perspective because her emotional journey drives the plot forward. By focusing on her inner turmoil and devotion to Jim, the reader experiences the anxiety, love, and hope she feels throughout the narrative. This perspective enhances the sentimental nature of the story, allowing readers to empathize with her struggle and fully appreciate the irony of their mutual sacrifices.
- Jim and Della’s selfless sacrifices should be praised, as they demonstrate deep love and devotion to each other. They prioritized their partner’s happiness over material possessions, illustrating that genuine love is measured by selflessness rather than wealth. Although their decisions led to ironic outcomes, their actions reflect strong emotional bonds, making their sacrifices admirable.
- Despite the unexpected twist, Jim and Della’s gifts were appreciated. Their reactions highlight their genuine love and recognition of each other’s sacrifice. Though the gifts became unusable, they symbolized their commitment and affection. The emotional impact of these sacrifices strengthened their relationship, proving that the act of giving held more value than the gifts themselves.
- If faced with a similar situation, I would likely experience mixed emotions—joy in finding the perfect gift, anxiety over the consequences of sacrifice, and hope that the gesture would be meaningful. However, after realizing the irony, I would choose to cherish the thoughtfulness behind the gift rather than its practicality.
- Jim and Della’s story teaches that both gift-giving and receiving require an appreciation of the intent behind the gesture. A thoughtful gift carries emotional weight beyond its physical value. This story reminds us that sacrifices made for loved ones should be recognized and valued, reinforcing the idea that true generosity is rooted in selflessness rather than materialism.
