Read the complete NYT review for Black Panther by Manohla Dargis below. When
you are finished reading, record your responses to the accompanying questions independently, or with a
partner. STUDENT CHOICE: ANSWER 5 OF THE 6 QUESTIONS.
Black Panther’ Shakes Up the Marvel Universe
- How does this reviewer give us enough explanation of the movie’s plot, characters, setting and
conflict so we have context for understanding her opinions? What lines or paragraphs do that
especially well?
The Correct Answer and Explanation is :
In Manohla Dargis’s review of Black Panther, she provides ample context regarding the film’s plot, characters, setting, and conflict, which is crucial for understanding her perspectives. The review effectively frames the narrative of the film, discussing the protagonist, T’Challa, who inherits the throne of Wakanda following the death of his father. Dargis describes Wakanda as a technologically advanced African nation that has kept its resources hidden from the world, setting the stage for the film’s central conflict. The review highlights the clash between T’Challa and Erik Killmonger, emphasizing their contrasting ideologies regarding leadership and identity. This explanation is critical in understanding the stakes and emotional depth of the film.
Dargis illustrates the setting of Wakanda by detailing its vibrancy and technological advancements, enhancing the reader’s understanding of its significance as both a utopian vision and a reflection of real-world issues. For example, her mention of “the deeply rooted traditions” juxtaposed with “the future of technology” captures the essence of Wakanda’s duality, which is central to the plot and character motivations.
Key lines that stand out include descriptions of T’Challa’s internal struggle with his role as king and his commitment to his people, along with the implications of Killmonger’s radical approach. These elements are woven throughout the review, providing a comprehensive picture of the film’s thematic complexity.
Overall, Dargis’s insightful commentary on the film’s characters and conflicts not only elucidates the narrative but also enhances the reader’s appreciation of the film’s cultural and social commentary. By articulating these components clearly, the review establishes a framework that enriches the understanding of the film and its impact within the Marvel Universe.