Thoreau writes, “we do not ride on the railroad; it rides upon us” (paragraph 2). consider an electronic device (such as a notebook computer, a cell phone, a pda, or an mp3 player). what would thoreau say about it? has this device helped to simplify our lives, or has it had a negative impact on them?
The Correct Answer and Explanation is:
Thoreau, in his famous work Walden, critiques the way modern conveniences, such as the railroad, increasingly control and shape human lives. When he writes, “we do not ride on the railroad; it rides upon us,” he suggests that the railroad, while initially a tool for convenience, ends up dominating the lives of individuals, making them more dependent on it and less connected to nature or their own sense of self. If Thoreau were to consider a modern electronic device like a cell phone or notebook computer, he would likely see it in a similar light—both a tool and a source of control.
Thoreau would argue that, while these devices may provide conveniences, they also complicate life by creating a sense of constant connectivity and distraction. A cell phone or computer, for example, has the potential to keep people perpetually tied to work, social media, or entertainment. Rather than offering the freedom that we might expect, these devices often contribute to stress, a loss of personal time, and an inability to focus on the present moment. Thoreau would likely suggest that, much like the railroad, these devices don’t just simplify our lives; they dominate them.
Thoreau would criticize the dependence on these devices as a form of enslavement to technology. He valued simplicity and self-reliance, and would probably contend that the devices we use every day, while designed to make life easier, often cause us to lose sight of what is essential—spending time in nature, engaging in meaningful reflection, and fostering genuine connections with others without the constant interruption of notifications.
In essence, Thoreau would view these electronic devices as an example of how technological progress, while offering certain conveniences, may ultimately have a negative impact on our lives, leading to more complexity, distractions, and a diminished sense of personal freedom.