Which of the following results is Useful (U) for the query [maps], English (US)? Select all that apply.
A) A result that contains road maps for European countries.
B) A Wikipedia article that defines the word “map” and discusses many kinds of maps, the history of maps, and the study of maps.
C) The Yahoo! Maps website at http://maps.yahoo.com/.
D) A satellite map of the U.S. that shows current weather conditions.
The correct answer and explanation is:
Correct Answer:
- A) Useful (U)
- C) Useful (U)
- D) Useful (U)
Explanation:
The query “[maps]” in English (US) is broad and ambiguous, potentially indicating a desire for a variety of content related to maps. This could include practical tools (e.g., navigation or map services), educational content, or specific types of maps. Here’s the rationale for each option:
A) A result that contains road maps for European countries.
This result is Useful because road maps are a relevant type of map. Although the query originates in English (US), it does not explicitly specify a geographic preference, so European road maps can still satisfy the informational need for those exploring or researching maps globally.
B) A Wikipedia article that defines the word “map” and discusses many kinds of maps, the history of maps, and the study of maps.
This result is not marked as Useful because the query is likely practical in intent (seeking map tools or resources) rather than educational or historical. While some users might find this content interesting, it does not align as closely with the likely user intent of finding interactive maps or tools.
C) The Yahoo! Maps website at http://maps.yahoo.com/.
This is clearly Useful because Yahoo! Maps is a popular tool for finding locations, getting directions, and exploring maps. It directly meets the potential user intent for accessing an interactive map service.
D) A satellite map of the U.S. that shows current weather conditions.
This is also Useful because it provides a specific and functional type of map that may interest users. The query “[maps]” is broad, and weather maps are a legitimate subcategory of maps that users might seek.
In summary, the practical and functional results (A, C, and D) align well with the broad query “[maps],” while option B, though informative, is less aligned with the most likely intent.